Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

Lenovo X300 vs MacBook Air Mossberg Bitchfight

Illustration for article titled Lenovo X300 vs MacBook Air Mossberg Bitchfight

After rediscovering the Lenovo X300, the Mighty Mossberg has analyzed it, inevitably pitting it against the Apple MacBook Air in a classic fight of blood, dead and more blood and dead. And you know exactly what the outcome is.

Advertisement

Here are the main points of the Lenovo X300, compared to the MacBook Air, according to Señor Don Walt Mossberg:

• Is thicker than MacBook Air. Winner: MacBook Air.

• Is heavier than MacBook Air. Winner: MacBook Air.

• Has less battery life in both tests and normal use (so much for SSD.) Winner: MacBook Air.

• Has way more ports. Winner: Lenovo X300.

• Has built-in DVD possibility. Winner: Lenovo X300.

• Has SSD drive built-in. Winner: Lenovo X300.

• Has WiMax connectivity. Winner: Lenovo X300.

• Has USB Wireless. Winner: Lenovo X300.

• Has GPS location-finding. Winner: Lenovo X300.

• Has higher screen resolution. Winner: Lenovo X300.

• Has a screen that stands up higher, leaving less viewing angle while travelling on plane. Winner: MacBook Air.

• Has slower processor. Winner: MacBook Air.

• Doesn't use Mac OS X Leopard. Winner: MacBook Air.

• Is more expensive at $2,476 with half battery and without DVD. It has SSD, but it doesn't add any advantage. More popular configuration is $3,000 with full battery and DVD drive. MacBook Air base model is $1,799. Winner: MacBook Air.

Advertisement

That's seven wins each. Does this mean there's no winner? It may look like technical tie, but my feeling is that he prefers the MacBook Air. At the end, it's all about the software and Walter Mossberg preference for Leopard (which could be debatable, even while I agree with him) plus the price, physical specs and battery life, makes the MacBook Air come ahead.

Still, it seems that both computers are right and wrong. At the end, it all depends on your personal taste, priorities and pet peeves. Or as Caesar Mossberg politely puts it: if you have the money and "you're happy with Windows," the Lenovo X300 is a "notable engineering accomplishment." [All Things D]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

kaisermachead
kaisermachead

If I had no choice other than these two, I'd have to go with the Air simply because I refuse to live with Windows only, and I don't care to get a patched OS to run on other hardware. Since I DO have a choice beyond these two, the standard Macbook is the clear winner for me. I get the ports, the same footprint (albeit heavier) a DVD drive and the OS I prefer.

That said, using the OS as a bullet point doesn't work. What WOULD work is simply saying that one supports more software than the other. Since VMware Fusion/Parallels/Boot Camp can be used on the Air to run Windows natively, technically, it wins the compatibility game, with the only caveat being the price of a legal copy of Windows.