Netflix’s Collectible ‘Patches’ Could Train Kids to Binge, Children’s Safety Group Warns [Updated]

Illustration for article titled Netflix’s Collectible ‘Patches’ Could Train Kids to Binge, Children’s Safety Group Warns [Updated]
Screenshot: Netflix

Netflix’s latest A/B test is drawing criticism from child advocacy groups.

On Friday, Variety reported that Netflix is testing collectible “patches” for some kids’ shows. These are collectible images that viewers gain access to after watching “Fuller House,” “Trollhunter” or “A Series of Unfortunate Events.” The patches are their own rewards, collecting them doesn’t offer any additional content, though Variety notes that parents are tweeting their kids’ love for the new system.


When reached for comment, a Netflix spokesperson told Gizmodo, “We are testing a new feature on select kids titles that introduces collectible items for a more interactive experience, adding an element of fun and providing kids something to talk about and share around the titles they love. We learn by testing and this feature may or may not become part of the Netflix experience.”

Though it’s apparently a limited test, one advocacy group is concerned it’s the start of Netflix rewarding children for unhealthy viewing habits.

“It’s designed to turn kids into lobbyists and undermine parents’ limits,” Josh Golin, Executive Director, of the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, told Gizmodo. The CCFC is a nonprofit concerned about corporations who market to children. “It’s just incredible to me that as we’re having this national conversation about persuasive design of tech and how tech is often designed for the benefit of tech companies at the expense of users well-being, that Netflix would test something like this,” Golin said.

There are already numerous concerns about how extended screen time impacts childhood development. The CCFC’s concern is that the new patch system will create a feedback loop wherein child viewers push for more screen time than they usually would because they want to be rewarded with the patches.


“Children like to collect things,” Golin explained. “So this will probably be incredibly effective at getting kids wanting to watch more and more Netflix. [Netflix] is using techniques that children certainly can’t understand and they’re developmentally vulnerable to, to get them to engage in activity which is not good for them.”

Netflix denied the bingeing/unlocking characterization. The patches themselves don’t allow access to new content and viewers don’t have to watch multiple episodes to collect them. (Oddly enough, however, there are locks on the patches as you collect them). Golin says parents should create firm rules around screen time and talk to their kids about the content they consume whether the patch test becomes permanent or not.


“Honestly, If Netflix was to roll this out right now and make this a major part of their kids’ programming, parents should reconsider whether they have Netflix.”


Update 3/14/18: Netflix reached out to say they’ve concluded the A/B test and won’t implement the new feature. Their statement is included:

We’ve concluded the test for patches and have decided not to move forward with the feature for kids. We test lots of things at Netflix in order to learn what works well - and what doesn’t work well - for our members.


Of course I have pages. I had pages five years ago. How anyone can believe I don’t defies belief.



Holy shit, this is not a good thing. It’s very clever on Netflix’s part, and my guess is that a lot of parents will overlook it and simply file it away in the “stupid-kids-thing-who-cares-whatever” mental bucket before moving on. A few things, though:

This will definitely encourage kids to watch more than they otherwise would. The whole unlocking-an-achievement thing has been proven time and time again to be more than enough to hook people, especially kids. This is no different than colored gems on an iPhone game, or gold coins in a video game, or lame anime creatures on trading cards. Chalk it up to collector mentality, kids craving competition, or just the gratifying thrill of any kind of affirmation or pseudo-award. They will eat it up. That the reward itself has no real value other than a momentary psychic rush is unimportant.

This sends a terrible message about television viewing generally. The implied message is that more TV is inherently better, and that the act of watching TV is a good thing in and of itself. Having watched it is as important as whatever you got out of the subject matter, and the need to “achieve” something is exerting undue influence over your kids’ judgment as to whether something is worth watching in the first place.

Obviously, kids these days are subjected to all manner of Skinner Box manipulations, but this is seriously annoying. I hope there’s at least an opt-out option, but I somehow doubt this will be the case.