Activists Gather at Google's Developer Conference to Protest Maps Results for Sham Abortion Clinics

Illustration for article titled Activists Gather at Google's Developer Conference to Protest Maps Results for Sham Abortion Clinics
Image: UltraViolet and CREDO Action

Google will kick off its annual developer conference on Tuesday, showing off its latest and greatest to the people building things for its platforms. But a group of activists want to hold the tech giant accountable for how these very platforms are manipulating some of its most vulnerable users. On Tuesday morning, two advocacy organizations are holding a protest at Google headquarters, urging the company to remove anti-abortion “crisis pregnancy centers” from search results for abortion services.


Crisis pregnancy centers are organizations that counsel women against having abortions, often posing as actual medical clinics and frequently dispensing false information about reproductive health. In 2014, Google agreed to remove paid ads for these centers after advocacy groups found that searches for “abortion clinics” delivered ads for crisis pregnancy centers around 79 percent of the time. However, opportunity for deception on Google’s platforms remains. Earlier this year, Gizmodo found that a Google Maps search for “Where can I get an abortion?” included crisis pregnancy centers in the results. When 20 people across the U.S. replicated this search query, all but two were served up crisis pregnancy centers in the Maps results.

Today, progressive advocacy organizations UltraViolet and CREDO are gathering at Charleston Park, which is the adjacent Googleplex, to deliver a petition before Sundar Pichai’s I/O keynote. The petition, which has collected over 100,000 signatures, urges Google to stop promoting crisis pregnancy centers to users looking for abortion services. The groups also plan to hold a light projection in a number of spots near the amphitheater where the Google conference is held. The projections will read: “Google, stop lying to women. No to fake, anti-abortion clinics.”

“Google is complicit in luring vulnerable, pregnant women to anti-abortion centers posing as legitimate reproductive health clinics that deceive, lie to, and shame them out of abortions,” Shaunna Thomas, co-founder of UltraViolet, said in a press release. “Users trust Google to be an honest broker here. The company must take action immediately to uphold its advertising policy and ensure abortion care search results are accurate.”

UltraViolet and CREDO note that the timing of Tuesday’s protest and petition closely align with a Supreme Court case dealing with similar issues. The case—NIFLA v. Becerra—deals with California’s Reproductive FACT Act, which was passed in 2015. The law requires licensed clinics to inform clients of certain services they provide, including ultrasounds, pregnancy tests, and abortion. It also requires unlicensed medical facilities that provide similar services to inform their clients that they don’t have a medical certification. The National Institute of Family and Life Advocates (NIFLA) filed a lawsuit against the legislation, arguing that it infringed on their freedom of speech. The case is ongoing.


As a pedantic cartophile that hates inaccurate maps Google is still fighting their structural information input problem that they first acknowledged when they completely shut down Google Maps Maker several years ago:

Enough people are brain dead fucking trolls that they ruin it for everyone.

For example - currently (as of May 8, 2018 at 33.6182280, -114.4530357) is this little gem of political activism:

Within feet of each other are two different markers for a single I-10 rest area with nothing nearby. After many attempts I got the actual official Ehrenberg Rest Area marker in Google Maps.

I have reported, seen and verified the removal of the inaccurate gunlovin marker several times but someone keeps putting it back.

I was kinda hoping that Google Maps’ “Local Guides” program, with its community feedback and points levels would help to weed out flyby trolling but Google will allow maps posting of unverified drek by even more unverified users.