Lawsuit Filed Against Apple and iOS App Makers Over Secret User Tracking

Illustration for article titled Lawsuit Filed Against Apple and iOS App Makers Over Secret User Tracking

Apple and a number of iPhone app makers including Pandora and were sued Monday for allegedly helping advertisers secretly create profiles of iPhone users, including their location, without their consent.

The suit, filed in federal court in Northern California, seeks both a court order to stop the profiling and monetary damages.

At issue is the practice of some app makers of passing identifying and location information about an app user to companies that show advertisements inside the apps. The apps do not ask permission to do so, nor do they make it clear to users that such information is being sent to third parties.


Other apps named in the suit include Toss It, Text4Plus, The Weather Channel, Talking Tom Cat, and Pimple Popper Lite.

The tracking is possible because Apple assigns a UDID (Unique Device Identifier) to each iPhone, iPod Touch and iPad, and apps can access that number. Advertising companies figured out this number – akin to a social security number for a phone - can be used for tracking, much like a cookie in a browser.

If an app passes along that number to an advertisers, the advertising company can use it to build up a profile of the user, as well as keep track of which ads it has shown to a user before and which of those ads a user clicked on.

With browser cookies, however, a user can easily block them or delete them, essentially cutting off the profile. Neither is possible with apps that use UDIDs, since that number can't be changed.


The suit contends that apps that send that UDID, along with location information, to third-parties violate computer and business fraud laws. Apple is likewise responsible, the suit argues, because it approves all apps for the iPhone.

"Apple knew this was an issue," said Majed Nachawati, one of the lawyers who filed the suit. "They had a duty to warn consumers and at a minimum, if they intend to profit from this, they need to let people know and get their consent."


Apple's developer rules were changed in the spring to prohibit apps from passing data to third party advertisers, a prohibition that many saw as favoring Apple's own in-app advertising program and which has not been enforced.

The practice of apps sending location data and the UDID came to light thanks to an investigation by the Wall Street Journal, published earlier this month.


Apple, unlike Google, approves every app that can be installed on a iPhone through the app store. While Apple says that's to protect users and the ecosystem, it's also the reason the company is named in the suit.

Defendant Apple, by exercising significant control over App developers and sharing profits with them, has created a "community of interest" with the other Defendants to render them joint venturers, who are responsible for each other's torts. Defendant Apple has also aided and abetted the remaining Defendants in the commission of their legal wrongs against Plaintiffs and the proposed class.


The suit also comes just weeks after the Commerce department and the Federal Trade Commission separately released reports calling for online advertising companies to clean up their acts and be more transparent with users.

A suit over companies using Adobe's Flash plug-in to track users without their consent recently settled for more than $2 million earlier this month.

Illustration for article titled Lawsuit Filed Against Apple and iOS App Makers Over Secret User Tracking
Advertisement has been expanding the hive mind with technology, science and geek culture news since 1995.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


Doesn't new apps, and most apps ask if they can use your location when they open them? Heaven forbid your shown ads that may be of interest to you. I guess I didn't realize they were doing this secretly...

Pandora for instance... gives you the option to either like or dislike a song. In certain regions... people's taste in music is different so if a lot of people from a certain region like a song... then they can use your location to feed you music liked by other people in that region.

Also... A lot of these apps are free... and the developers have to make money somehow... Why not make money with targeted ads... just like Hulu, and Yahoo, and AOL, and every other advertising outlet has been doing for years.

The more I think about this the more I'm annoyed. People really need to quit being so damn petty... you don't want the world to know what you like... get yourself a tracfone and cut your internet service.