Michael Moore’s Garbage Planet of the Humans Has Been Removed From YouTube

Illustration for article titled Michael Moore’s Garbage Planet of the Humans Has Been Removed From YouTube
Image: Planet of the Humans

Michael Moore’s Planet of the Humans is a trash film that contains massive amounts of disinformation and dabbles in ecofascism. Turns out it also contained copyrighted material.

Advertisement

The film racked up 8 million views and gained major traction with climate deniers and right wing groups thanks to YouTube hosting it and featuring it on Earth Day. But now the platform has pulled the video over copyright infringement. Good riddance.

Planet of the Humans is full of problematic themes. The so-called documentary ignores the promise of solar and wind energy, relying on an outmoded view of the industry. It then offers population control as the solution to the climate crisis. This line of thinking is dangerous. It borders on eco-fascism, which props up white supremacy for the sake of saving the planet. No thanks, dude.

Toby Smith, an environmental photographer, found another issue with the film: It contains some of his work without his permission. He was not happy to see, and he didn’t waste time trying to work with Gibbs and Moore. He went straight to YouTube, filing a complaint over the weekend.

“I went directly to YouTube rather than approaching the filmmakers because I wasn’t interested in negotiation,” Smith said to the Guardian. “I don’t support the documentary. I don’t agree with its message, and I don’t like the misleading use of facts in its narrative.”

YouTube is notoriously bad at taking down content. But the streaming video service listened in this case and took the film down to due to Smith’s complaint. It’s something environmental groups and climate scientists have been pushing for since the film’s Earth Day release, though for different reasons.

Advertisement

The company has a record of profiting off undeniably awful shit like pedophilia, misinformation, and hate speech. Every click, every view—even those supporting conspiracy theories or lies—sends money the company’s way. Climate denial, in particular, is big on the video streamer’s platform and another source of the company’s profits. A study last year found that conspiracy theorists and misinformation dominate the platform’s climate science content, and Planet of the Humans is the most high profile addition. Most recently, the company has come under fire for making money off videos promoting dangerous and unproven coronavirus cures, including “videos pushing herbs.”

The film’s director, Jeff Gibbs, is trying to bring the film back online. He sees its removal as “another attempt by the film’s opponents to subvert the right to free speech,” per a statement to Deadline. There’s a good chance that climate deniers will rally around this, adding fuel to the fire. It could also add fuel to the fire of untrue claims of conservatives griping about liberal bias online, including the president himself.

Advertisement

Will YouTube bring this dumb-ass movie back? I sure hope not. People need facts these days. One fewer terrible YouTube video alone won’t fix the climate misinformation crisis, but at least the company won’t keep making money off it.

Yessenia Funes is climate editor at Atmos Magazine. She loves Earther forever.

DISCUSSION

ibell
ibell

Copyright issues aside.

First: People keep calling this ‘Micheal Moore’s film.’ It’s not. He produced it. Which is different.

I know they’re fine with marketing it this way because they’ll get more attention, but it’s not “Michael Moore’s Garbage Film,” it’s Jeff Gibb’s “Garbage film.” Give him the credit he deserves.

Second: I also find that the film, though definitely short sighted, does present some realities of the renewable energy industry—realities that may happed to be inconvenient for those promoting a renewable future. I didn’t watch the whole film, because it was badly edited and repetitive to the point were I was done with it a bit more than halfway through, but I think it would have (could have) been a fine 40 min film about how the current renewable energy sector is a political, social and economic work in progress; a shell game riddled with greenwashing, and manipulation by the fossil fuel industry, politicians and lobbyists.

Hard stop.

This may be one of those times you throw the baby out with the bathwater, but just because someone says something true that you don’t like, mixed up in a package of other dumb shit, doesn’t mean you dismiss it outright. It just means you excise the bullshit and keep moving.