Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

Samsung's Defense: Apple Stole It First

Apple just spent a week methodically making the case that Samsung ripped off its patents and trademarks for the design of its smartphones and tablets. It was pretty convincing. Are you ready for Samsung's brilliant defense? "Actually, Apple stole it from us." Oh brother.

Advertisement

On Monday, Samsung tried to refute Apple's claim over pinch-to-zoom technology. How? By claiming it already existed on a weird Mitsubishi product called Diamond Touch. As you can see in the video above, Diamond Touch basically consists of a display projected onto a large table that you then interact with in a variety of ways using your hands. Amongst the many gestures is one which resembles pinch-to-zoom.

Advertisement

But it seems Samsung's argument is based on an ambiguity that's just not there. Because Apple's technology existed in broad, conceptual forms in other places, Apple can't lay claim to it. Except that what's really at issue here is Apple's specific implementations of these technologies and—more importantly—its ownership over that intellectual property. [San Jose Mercury News via Fortune via BGR]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

saidear
DeadInBowlingGreen

Do you really need a stupidly sensationalist article about a topic Gizmodo ALREADY wrote about in a less biased manner?

http://gizmodo.com/5934510/samsung-challenges-apple-pinch+to+zoom-patent-with-2001-tech