The dirty secret about robot vacuums is that they can’t actually clean your entire house. They’re great for floors, but are completely useless for cleaning all of your other other dust-covered surfaces. It’s a problem the Coral One—a robovac with a removable handheld cleaner—was engineered to solve. Its design is undoubtedly a clever solution to the problem, but the execution, unfortunately, isn’t the answer to our robovac woes.
As far as smarthome robots go, robotic vacuums are really the only automatons that offer any genuinely useful functionality. And while over the past 16 years robovacs have improved to the point where you never have to manually vacuum your floors ever again, there are lots of other places that need cleaning—like sofas, dressers, tables, or kitchen counters—where a robovac can’t help.
So when you’re budgeting $950 for iRobot’s latest and greatest Roomba, you’ll also need to factor in the additional cost of a second vacuum to tidy all your non-floor surfaces. That gets expensive fast, and it makes the $495 Coral One seem even more appealing given it’s an all-in-one dirt-sucking solution. But it’s a first-generation product from a company that was only just founded in March, and it unfortunately also functions like a first-generation product.
As industrial design goes, the Coral One, available in a glossy black or white finish, is one of the more beautiful robovac designs I’ve tested. It’s a fingerprint magnet, and easily scratched, but robovacs tend to look more like robots designed for factories, than an accessory designed to roam around your well-appointed home.
On the underside you’ll find the same basic features that most robovacs now rely on, with a pair of spring-loaded, deeply-treaded wheels that allow the robot to clamber over uneven surfaces (think wood floor to carpet transitions), a rotating brush drum to help dislodge dirt, and a spinning set of removable whiskers to help sweep dirt stuck in corners or along the edges of a room. Unfortunately, after getting trapped under a bed, the whiskers on the Coral One got chewed up as the robot tried to work its way free, but they still function as intended.
The Coral One’s footprint is comparable to other robovacs on the market, including the Neato D4, seen sitting next to it above. But the Coral One is at least an inch taller than the D4, which means it will have a much harder time squeezing under your furniture. It’s a good example of why the removable hand vac is such a good idea, for tidying areas where the Coral One in robot mode can’t reach.
But unlike most of its competitors, the Coral One doesn’t connect to your home’s wifi network or an app for operating it remotely. Instead, a small set of onboard buttons are used to start and stop a cleaning cycle, switch between standard and turbo cleaning modes, send it back to the dock for charging or change the language it speaks. Those buttons are mirrored on a tiny remote should you want to start the bot from afar, and the Coral One’s dock features a clock and programmable start time for daily cleanings, but that’s about as complicated as the robovac gets.
On one hand, it makes the Coral One very easy to set up and use, and there are no concerns about privacy given it doesn’t upload any data about your home or its cleaning routine. But on the other hand, it means the vacuum lacks much of the advanced functionality that makes other robovacs so useful now. You can’t set up virtual boundaries on a map like Neato’s robo-cleaners can, nor can you get software updates that improve the robot’s functionality over time.
And that is one of my biggest concerns with the Coral One, because while it does rely on a collection of sensors to navigate a room, avoid obstacles, and plan out a cleaning routine—out of the gate it’s not really great at any of those things, and over time that’s not going to change.
I have tested countless robovacs over the years, and not even the earliest Roombas careened around a room as the Coral One does. Instead of slowly tip-toeing around furniture and obstacles like other robovacs do (Neato’s D7 is very good at this) the Coral One tends to just bump into objects, with enough force to even move chairs around a room, before backing away and heading off in another direction. At one point it almost toppled a standing vase the robovac’s top-mounted IR sensor couldn’t have missed, and as a result, I’m actually hesitant to let it clean a room without supervision.
So what about the Coral One’s other flagship feature: the removable hand vac? It’s a very clever design and removing it from the robot is as easy as pushing a release button and yanking the portable cleaner away, which includes the Coral One’s motor and battery.
I wish I could say this is where the Coral One shines, but I can’t. It takes the handvac about five seconds to get up to full suction power when you turn it on (and even longer to completely spin down afterward) and even then it’s not that powerful. And that’s not comparing it to a $700 top-of-the-line handheld Dyson, either. I remember the handheld Dirt Devil I used to clean my college dorm room having far more suction than this does.
The Coral One’s handvac also ships with just two accessories: a crevice tool and a brush attachment for fabrics. What’s sorely missing is a long extension tube and a head for cleaning parts of your floor the robovac can’t reach. Like it or not, robot vacuums aren’t perfect, and there’s always going to be spots they miss. But being able to quickly switch the machine to a manual floor vac would be the perfect workaround, and it’s something I hope the creators of the Coral One consider for future versions of the product.
When it was first announced last month, the Coral One seemed like it would be a great alternative to the countless robovacs on the market. I still think the inclusion of a removable handheld vacuum is a clever innovation: I just wish it had been better executed.
As a first-generation product, the Coral One leaves a lot to be improved, and without the benefit of wifi connectivity, those improvements are only going to be available on future generations of the robovac. Its unique design has a lot of potential, and I won’t be surprised to see others copying what the Coral One can do. I just hope that someone is able to eventually deliver what this one doesn’t.
- A clever innovation on robot vacuums that addresses the limitations of where a robovac can actually clean.
- Setting up and using the Coral One is very easy, but a lack of connectivity limits the robovac’s features, and future software upgrades.
- The Coral One’s obstacle detection almost seems non-existent, and more often than not it only knows when an object is in its path when it hits it. At times it feels like a bull in a China shop.
- The handheld vacuum comes with just two attachments, and the suction power is disappointing.
- At $495 it’s about as expensive as robot vacuums like the Neato D4 or the iRobot Roomba e5 which both offer far more features and performance.
Correction, 12:53 p.m. EST/EDT: This review incorrectly referred to the sensor atop the Coral One as a 360-degree camera, when it in fact is an infrared sensor that doesn’t capture or store images of your home in order to maximize privacy.