President Donald Trump has nominated Palantir’s chief information security officer, Michael LoSapio, to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA). He’s scheduled for a Senate confirmation hearing on Thursday, November 19, and would inherit an agency that has lost roughly a third of its workforce under Trump. CISA has also scaled back its assistance to critical infrastructure operators, even as the administration pushes AI-driven tools to strengthen the nation’s cyber defenses. That raises a troubling question: Can an agency with fewer people and fewer resources still protect the country’s power grids, water systems, and other essential infrastructure at a time when those systems seem more vulnerable than ever?
In August, CISA acting director Nick Andersen told attendees at Black Hat USA that the agency was “ruthlessly prioritizing” new hires. That’s a message Andersen has kept up, saying “hundreds” of new workers would soon join the agency.
“With the emerging threat space that we continue to see, do I have the right people in the right roles right now to be able to meet that challenge?” Andersen told reporters in September.
The only problem? Andersen doesn’t have the right people in the right roles, and it’s a self-inflicted problem after Donald Trump’s administration slashed CISA’s budget by hundreds of millions and drove off many of its career staff.
Cuts upon cuts
CISA is the agency that Congress established to help federal agencies, critical infrastructure, and the private sector establish secure perimeters in cyberspace in 2018. James A. Lewis, a researcher at the Center for European Policy Analysis and one of the architects of pre-Trump cyber policy, told Gizmodo that if there’s a point where CISA has ceased to be functional, “We’ve reached it.”
“They lost at least a third of their staff, a huge chunk of their budget, and so it’s just hard for them to do their jobs,” Lewis added.
CISA previously enjoyed bipartisan support, one of the perks of being a national security agency in a post-9/11 (and post-Colonial Pipeline) government. Advocates had long argued the U.S. was overconfident in its cyber defenses, and needed a coordinating agency to help identify and fill gaps.
“I worked in DoD cyber policy, and it was a broad misunderstanding that the Department of Defense was responsible for defending all U.S. networks,” Emerson Brooking, a non-resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, told Gizmodo. “…That is explicitly not the mission of U.S. cyber forces.”
“The broad and very important civilian defense mission was always kind of passed off to CISA,” Brooking added.
That soured at the end of Trump’s first term, and it’s continued to go downhill in the second.
“I was not cautiously optimistic,” Lewis said. “He blamed them for his election woes, and you notice that the guy was a little vindictive.”
Chris Krebs, the agency’s founding director, was fired in 2020 by Trump after publicly affirming the security of that year’s election, contradicting Trump’s baseless fraud claims. Republicans also conflated CISA’s efforts to fight election misinformation with other DHS programs, including an internal advisory board that eventually disbanded under concentrated political fire.
Despite the lack of evidence that CISA went rogue—subsequent chief Jen Easterly often emphasized that the agency had no intent of becoming a regulator—Trump has run with it. In April 2025, Trump signed an extraordinary presidential memorandum effectively portraying Krebs as a threat to national security, and his administration subsequently asked Congress to cut $495 million from CISA’s budget and eliminate nearly a third of its positions.
Congress softened the cuts to around $300 million, but the agency lost a third of its weary staff to layoffs and attrition. High-profile forced departures or resignations this year alone have included CIO Bob Costello, cybersecurity division leader Shelly Hartsook, and HR chief Kevin Diana.
Trump’s proposed budget for fiscal year 2027 would give CISA roughly $2.49 billion, $386 million less than its 2025 funding, according to the Congressional Research Service. If passed—the government is currently operating under a continuing resolution through December 11—the budget would require further cuts, including hefty reductions for its Cybersecurity Division. The Wall Street Journal reported in September that private-sector firms were receiving “mixed signals” from remaining CISA supporters in Congress and the White House about CISA’s future.
CISA’s remaining field operations to assist critical infrastructure operators are “either most or entirely under the knife in this FY 27 CISA proposal” released by the White House, Brooking said. He argued Andersen’s handful of new hires is “not durable, and he’s kind of bragging about this at the same time the administration has advanced a budget that cuts CISA even more deeply.”
“It’s deeply confused,” Brooking added.
“Two years ago, I met with the state association of water utilities from one of the biggest states in the country, and it was helpless back then,” Lewis told Gizmodo. “A lot of them are little local facilities that got like 12 employees; one guy does cybersecurity in his spare time. This is where not having CISA to backstop them is a problem.”
In late August, CISA axed six types of cybersecurity assessments that its regional staff previously offered to perform for critical infrastructure operators for free, amid workforce and resource shortages. The agency said it was eliminating redundant services. According to Cybersecurity Dive, the agency instead directed operators to its Cross-Sector Cybersecurity Performance Goals, effectively replacing live assistance on identifying security gaps with a questionnaire and non-interactive guidance.
Both experts agreed that CISA had stumbled into a minefield attempting to intervene against election misinformation. Lewis said he’d spoken to other former officials who believed the agency should “focus on a little more technical skill, [be] a little more focused on the cybersecurity mission.” Mass firings, he said, obviously don’t accomplish that.
“This is not a field where there’s a shortage of job offers, and so talent left, and now they’re going to have trouble replacing it,” Lewis told Gizmodo.
“There’s a handful of allegations where CISA workers may have overstepped bounds, but then [the White House] also have a problem with the broad project of election defense,” Brooking said. “Period.”
What’s more, cuts to CISA have coincided with Congress kicking the can down the road on renewing a separate 2015 law named CISA that provides liability protection for firms that share information on cyber threats. Congress has only renewed it through December 11, with congressional delays complicating efforts to reach a longer-term deal. [In November, 35 industry groups urged lawmakers to extend the law through 2035.] The ambiguity and lack of resources have seriously damaged the circulation of threat intelligence, Lewis said, which many legislators remain ignorant of.
“They keep limping along,” Lewis added. “It’s pathetic… When you talk to people on the Hill, they thought CISA the agency and CISA the information-sharing bill were the same.”
Gold Eagle
This is all happening in the context of two emerging threats. One is a spate of cyberattacks on domestic utility systems conducted by both ransomware gangs and Iran-affiliated hackers. The other is frontier AI models that continue to discover both vulnerabilities and new ways to exploit them at a staggering rate, setting up an AI arms race between attackers and defenders.
Both experts noted that the Trump administration seems to be pivoting to AI-driven defenses, with Lewis pointing to Gold Eagle. That’s a joint initiative between AI companies, CISA, and the departments of Treasury, Homeland Security, and War that aims to use frontier AI models to patch vulnerabilities at scale. Secretary of War Pete Hegseth characterized Gold Eagle as “bringing a wartime footing to the cyber domain to relentlessly patch vulnerabilities.”
“The problem is, it’s voluntary, and no one will voluntarily share information unless they have the protections that CISA 2015 provides,” Lewis said. CISA is listed by the White House as a Gold Eagle partner, but Lewis argued it should be leading the effort rather than taking a supporting role, especially given that it already collects and publishes information on known exploited vulnerabilities.
Brooking said U.S. officials are approaching AI as though being “able to retain the most exquisite cyber capabilities” is the most important factor in defense.
“But, like, if you’re running a municipal water plant, you don’t need this hot shit 5 trillion parameter model to target you in order for your system to be vulnerable,” Brooking cautioned. “A much weaker model can achieve the same effects, and you can now run those basically anywhere in the world at a very low cost.”
“AI doesn’t unlock anything that new in hacking,” he added. “It’s more just the target set you can explore increases exponentially.”
“AI is not like the magic wand that will save us,” Lewis said. “… Not if you don’t have legal authorities and organization behind it.”
CISA’s future
Brooking noted that some members of Congress have promised to protect CISA from cuts that deep, but the situation “remains extremely turbulent and it’s definitely not good for cyber defense.”
And there’s a new political wrinkle. Democrats will take control of Congress in January, and Rep. Bennie Thompson, who is expected to lead the House Homeland Security Committee, has said rebuilding CISA’s workforce will be a priority. Thompson and other Democratic lawmakers have also called for an investigation into the effects of the staffing cuts on the agency’s ability to protect critical infrastructure.
In September, Cybersecurity Dive reported that Andersen said CISA was trying to hire workers with broad, rather than specialized, knowledge.
“I don’t want to hire somebody that’s just going to work with the electric sector,” Andersen told reporters at a Google security summit. “I want to hire somebody who can understand the operational-technology concepts and the control-system concepts that can broadly have applicability across the electricity subsector and the oil, natural gas subsector, and water and wastewater, and so forth and so on.”
It’s worth noting that Andersen has separately said he wants CISA to focus on “crown jewels” in infrastructure, or those whose disruption would cause the most harm, rather than the entire potential attack surface. In October, the agency formalized that approach in its CISA 2030 strategy, promising to concentrate resources on infrastructure whose failure would have the greatest consequences. The plan calls for reviewing CISA’s services, but doesn’t specify which might lose resources. So perhaps this staffing strategy is more out of necessity than intent.
Lewis said any effort to undo damage to CISA “will take time, and we may not have time.”
“The question is: Has CISA been punished enough for its election transgressions that they’ll take the pressure off it?” Lewis asked. “It’s an agency that you need to have. Let’s see if they can rebuild it.”