Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

Woman With Leprosy Denied Pension Because She Doesn't Have Fingers for India's Biometric Database

An operator helps an elderly woman scan her fingerprints as she enrolls for Aadhar. (Photo: AP)
An operator helps an elderly woman scan her fingerprints as she enrolls for Aadhar. (Photo: AP)

Blind, disabled, and estranged from her family, 65-year-old Sajidha Begum has survived on a monthly pension check of 1,000 rupees (about $16) in Bangalore, India. In August, however, the Indian government sent a letter to the leprosy hospital where she’s lived for over 10 years saying her pension was being taken away unless it was linked to a card from Aadhaar, the country’s controversial biometric database. But since leprosy has taken Begum’s sight and fingers, she has no way of submitting the necessary fingerprints and iris scans—and no prospective solution as she awaits help.

Advertisement

Aadhaar (meaning “foundation”) is India’s enormous, country-wide biometric database. Mandated by the Indian government, 1.17 billion people are in the system, which assigns 12-digit codes linked to iris scans and fingerprints to everyone living and working in the country. India began collecting biometric data for the system back in 2009 and many subsidies and entitlements, like pensions for the disabled and elderly, are credited to Aadhaar-linked bank accounts.

Fingerprints and iris scans are mandatory for verification in the Aadhaar system, but Begum simply can’t provide them. She’s lost her hands, her sight, and her feet to leprosy. Dr Ayub Ali Zai, the administrative medical officer for the leprosy hospital where Begum has stayed for years, wrote a letter alongside The Indian Express to the Indian government asking for an exemption for her. They were denied.

Advertisement

“Even if the woman doesn’t have sight, there may be biometrics that the machine can read,” an official told them. “Only when the machine is unable to read and they get a rejection letter, it can be considered at the back end. There are cases where leprosy patients have got Aadhaar with whatever is left of their biometrics.”

The World Health Organization estimates 200,000 people annually contract the disease in India each year. Dr. Zai told the Express that other patients in the hospital have the same problem. As amputees, they can’t provide biometrics and requests for exemptions are either ignored or denied outright. Aadhaar was built to establish a “digital identity” in an enormous nation with migrant workers who often don’t have ID.

Begum’s story is heartbreaking. Fortunately, a few Express readers have apparently reached out to donate to Begum. In the meantime, a treasury official told the paper that Begum’s case “is being looked into.”

[Indian Express]

Advertisement

Of course I have pages. I had pages five years ago. How anyone can believe I don’t defies belief.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

West Coast Secessionist

So, bear with me here.

I remember when Touch ID came out people experimented and were able to get it working by enrolling random body parts, like nipples. Now, I’m not suggesting that one of course, but does anyone know what body parts might work? A knuckle? The stubs where her fingers used to be? (that poor woman). I suppose though that it depends on whether the machine tries to detect if it’s not a fingerprint and rejects it.

Also, so sad that they can’t just allow her to bypass the process. Do they really think anybody is trying to catch leprosy, go blind, and lose their fingers in order to scam a few bucks of pension money? I don’t think anybody does that.