Can Los Angeles Become A "No Kill" City For Pets?

Illustration for article titled Can Los Angeles Become A No Kill City For Pets?

Here's the thing about euthanizing animals in pet shelters: nobody wants to do it. It's simply a consequence of an imbalance between supply and demand. More unwanted animals wind up in increasingly overcrowded shelters than are adopted out.

The root of the problem is a welfare tradeoff. Is it better to house fewer animals at a reasonable density, or more animals in overcrowded conditions? Which is more important: quality of life or length of life? It's a similar trade-off as the one at the heart of the recent conflict over Marius, the Copenhagen Zoo's late juvenile giraffe.

Building more and bigger shelters is perhaps one way to deal with the overcrowding problem, but that only moves the goalposts slightly, and may not be feasible given the 25,000 animals that LA County had to euthanize in 2013. A better solution might be to provide better incentives for folks to adopt from shelters rather than to purchase their pets from breeders, and perhaps to offer mechanisms for providing lower-cost healthcare, including contraception or sterilization, for pets. Which is a tall order, to be sure.


Still, according to reporter Sarah Sax who produced this story for the University of Southern California's Annenberg TV News, LA's rate of euthanasia is down nearly 50% compared to 2012, which could be a promising sign if the trend continues.

Header image: FEMA/Public domain.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter



I worked for a large inner city shelter that took in 11,500 animals in one year. I personally probably euthanized 800 of them, mostly cats. We need nothing short of a cultural shift that gets people to respect cats and dogs as domestic companions. Peer pressure works for this and that is backed up by science. Call people out when you hear them talk about these species as though they are chairs or garbage to be gotten rid of. I also worked for a no-kill and when I moved on to Biology I opened a no kill shelter at our home for local cats (we only took in 7 cats but found homes for all of them). Open door shelters (what are sadly known as "kill") are better because they don't turn down any animals. At the same time quality of life is what's important. We simply need more no-kill foster homes so cats can live indoors with plenty of room in a loving home. The open door shelters take in every animal but simply being a killing factory is no good. If you don't give a crap about the animals, just remember there is a human being who has to kill your companion for you and that's not fair either.