Electroconvulsive Therapy Can Erase Unwanted Memories

Illustration for article titled Electroconvulsive Therapy Can Erase Unwanted Memories

We're still a far ways off from the kind of memory erasure portrayed in the film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, but a recent experiment has just taken us one step closer. By using electroconvulsive therapy on depressed patients, scientists were able to disrupt their ability to recall emotionally jarring events.


Every time we recall a memory we have to take it out of our mental storage banks. According to theory, these memories have to be re-written back onto the brain's circuits each them they're accessed. It's an imperfect process called memory reconsolidation, and it's the crucial idea behind a recent experiment conducted by Marijn Kroes and his colleagues from Radboud University Nijmegen.

Related: Would you erase painful memories if you could? | Erase your memories of being afraid

By using electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), which was once called electroshock therapy, the neuroscientists were hoping to disrupt this reconsolidation process. They wanted to disturb the re-formation of disturbing or unwanted memories in patients suffering from depression. In future, a more refined technique could be used to treat mental trauma, psychiatric disorders, and drug addiction.

For the experiment, Kroes took 39 patients who were undergoing ECT for severe depression (ECT works by passing electrical currents to parts of the brain, which triggers a brief seizure; patients are given muscle relaxants and an anesthetic). Each patient was asked to watch two rather upsetting videos, one about a child who is hit by a car and has to have his feet severed by surgeons, the other involving a pair of sisters, one of whom is kidnapped and sexually assaulted.


A week later, the patients were asked to recall details about one of the two stories (not both), after which time they were randomly sorted into three groups, A, B, and C (a control group).

Members of Group A and B were treated with ECT immediately following the retelling of the story. The following day, Group A participants had to complete a multiple-choice quiz about both stories. Fascinatingly, they did a better job recalling the story for which their memories hadn't been reactivated (or reconsolidated). Their recall ability for the recounted story was no better than chance. Group B, on the other hand, had their memories tested about 90 minutes after the ECT, and their recall abilities were intact — suggesting that it takes time to impair a memory. Group C did not receive ECT at all, and their recall abilities were solid, indicating that both ECT and reconsolidation is required to impair memory recall.


So this study furthers the memory reconsolidation theory. The technique could also prove useful for therapists — albeit a very blunt one.

Read the entire study at Nature Communications: "An electroconvulsive therapy procedure impairs reconsolidation of episodic memories in humans."


Image: SOURCE1

Neuroscience, memory, memory consolidation, electroconvulsive therapy, memory erasure, science




Before a bunch of people start gaping in horror about ECT, I want to post this:

ECT is not like it is portrayed in the movies. Just like most things!

ECT is the single most effective form of treatment for severe, prolonged depression with fixed suicidal ideation. It is almost never done until the patient has failed to respond to multiple different medications.

Yes, there is sometimes some short term memory loss. However, it usually comes back. More importantly, being on anti-depressants for years and years can also seriously affect your cognitive processing, as well as your your weight, your sex drive, your liver, etc. If they don't end up making you more suicidal, which is listed as a possible side effect. That probably happens more often than severe, permanent memory loss as a result of ECT.