Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

First Broken iPhone 4 Screen

Illustration for article titled First Broken iPhone 4 Screen

The iPhone is made of aluminosilicate glass. Apple says it's "chemically strengthened to be 20 times stiffer and 30 times harder than plastic" and it's "ultradurable and more scratch resistant than ever." Still not enough to survive a 3.5-foot drop.

Advertisement

That's what the people at iFixyouri did: Test Apple's claims by dropping the iPhone 4 from 3.5 feet, the distance you drop a phone when you're standing up. They say their iPhone—which they claim is real, but without any internal components—survived the first two shocks.

On the third one, however, the display was completely shattered after a loud pop. That's a sound I'm personally familiar with: My current iPhone 3G's display has broken two times in the same way.

Advertisement
Illustration for article titled First Broken iPhone 4 Screen

It's not surprising that the Cupertino company is releasing a protective case of their own called the "bumper". Because now, unlike older iPhones where there's one side that has a display and one side that's plastic or aluminum—where you don't care if it gets messed up or cracked—now both sides are glass. Which means both sides are susceptible to breaking. My iPhone was dropped on its display face two times and broke two times. I lost count on the times it dropped on its back.

Illustration for article titled First Broken iPhone 4 Screen

This new material—20 times stiffer and 30 times harder than plastic—still shatters when dropped. But is it scratch-proof? More scratch-resistant? The test doesn't say. Having both sides be more scratch resistant—the backs of everyone's phones is most likely much more scuffed than the front—is a good thing, if it really is. But having the phone, as a whole, be more likely to break from drops is a bad thing.

Advertisement

And picture the scenario where you have to put your phone down on concrete. Previously, you just it down back first, because you didn't care what the back looks like. Now that the black is shiny and smooth and glass, what do you do? (Oh yes, Apple's own bumper case.)

I agree with Steve that the all-glass-and-steel design is beautiful, but its beauty is pointless if I have to hide it in order to protect it from drops. That's not what Dieter Rams would want in a product: "Good design is aesthetic" he said, but "good design is durable" too. There's a key difference between hardness and brittleness, and although the new glass screen might be harder, it doesn't mean it's not that brittle and likely to shatter when dropped on. (More on this from the comments.)[Ifixyouri]

Advertisement

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

robotronic-old
Robotronic

No internal components, no proof that it's real, and shatter marks that look like it was thrown at the floor, not dropped. Oh yeah, and from a no-name company that tries to sell repair services.

Questionable validity, to say the least.