So yeah, much of Incarceron feels like a retread of previous dystopian outings, but the good news is, it moves at a zippy pace and there are enough interesting revelations and fun twists to keep you interested. The main dilemmas the characters face are genuinely engrossing — Finn is torn between his dreams of greatness and loyalty to his scummy Oath Brother, Keiro, who's followed him from their prison-gang roots. Claudia is caught between her two father figures: her father the Warden and Jared, her teacher who's part of a mysterious group of scholars known as the Sapients. (Finn has a Sapient of his own, Gildas, following him.)

What saves Incarceron from being a bit of a paint-by-numbers fantasy about a lost Prince and a rebellious Princess is the concept of Incarceron itself — it starts out looking like your standard underground city/prison, but the more we learn about it, the more intriguing it becomes. Everyone in the outside world is taught that Incarceron is a perfect world, where society's rejects live in peace and plenty. But not surprisingly, it's a total cesspit where only the strong survive.

But it gets more interesting — Incarceron is artificially intelligent, with glowing red eyes that watch all of the prisoners all the time. The prison has a spiteful personality, and it's especially pissed off that it can't observe the outside world, because its eyes only turn inwards. Also, the prison is a closed system, so nothing goes to waste. When people die, their bodies are taken away and reconstituted as something else. New people are grown or made out of the remains of old people, and some of the newer people and creatures are cybernetic: half organic, half metal. Most intriguingly, there are hints that the people the prison makes out of its dead share some memories and other traits with the people they're made out of. And one dead person's essence could be parcelled out among dozens of newly constructed people, making for a weird type of immortality. The prison literally absorbs people and then spits them out in new, often weirder forms — I'm reminded of the Remade from Perdido Street Station a bit.


There's also one other giant revelation about the prison, which I won't give away here but is genuinely clever and fascinating.

And because the book has such a fascinating central conceit, it elevates all the stuff where both Claudia and Finn are prisoners in different ways, and their struggles to escape parallel each other. Just as Finn has to worry about the prison literally absorbing his essence so that it can create something new and potentially monstrous, Claudia freaks out about losing herself at court. At one point, she says:

This place scares me. At home, I know who I am, what to do. I'm the Warden's daughter, I know where I stand. But this is a dangerous place, full of pitfalls. All my life I've known it was waiting for me, but now I'm not sure I can face it. They'll want to absorb me, make me one of them, and I won't change. I wont! I want to stay me.


So the ultimate horror that both Finn and Claudia face is loss of individuality, or selfhood, at the hands of the oppressive machine. And that machine thrives on ignorance and secrets, forcing our heroes to be detectives and revealers of the truth to save themselves. It's a tried and true formula, but the weirdness and creepiness of the sentient prison elevates it to new levels.

Incarceron is also engagingly written, with exciting action set pieces and tons of plot twists, some of which are genuinely startling. It's a very quick read, and it's easy to root for the noble Finn and the independent Claudia. Apparently, it's the first book of a trilogy, but Fisher doesn't hold back too much for the following books — I was getting nervous towards the end that it would wind up with an unsatisfying cliffhanger, but there was enough resolution in the first book to feel worthwhile. (Not unlike the Hunger Games, say, this ends with a transformative victory, but there's still plenty of turmoil ahead.)


So if you, or your kids, are addicted to YA dystopias and haven't yet checked out Incarceron, it's a pretty great addition to the genre, and it shows how the genre is maturing and developing more archetypes. If you're new to YA dystopia, there are some other books you might want to check out first, including the aforementioned Hunger Games and City Of Ember.