Navajo and Hopi Tribes Are Losing Coal Jobs In Trump's America

Photo: AP
Photo: AP

Members of the Navajo Nation and Hopi Tribe were out with their picket signs outside the Arizona Capitol Tuesday, protesting the closure of the Navajo Generating Station and the Kayenta Mine.

Advertisement

The coal mine and the power plant where the coal has been processed for the last 40 years are set to shut down by the end of 2019. That is, unless a new owner shows up, which doesn’t appear to be happening. And, well, these tribal nations aren’t too happy about it.

The Kayenta Mine—the state’s only operating coal mine—and the Navajo Generating Station have been a major source of employment and income for the Navajo Nation and Hopi Tribe: 90 percent of the plant’s employees are Navajo, and 99 percent of mine employees are Native American. According to data shared by the Navajo Nation Council last year, revenues from the mine and plant make up 80 percent of the Hopi Tribe’s general budget and more than 30 percent of the Navajo Nation’s annual revenue.

The Navajo Generating Station. Photo: AP
The Navajo Generating Station. Photo: AP

However, coal is dying. Natural gas and renewable energy are taking over. More than 16,000 megawatts of coal energy is set to retire in the near future; two-thirds are expected to go offline this year, reports S&P Global. The utility owners of the Navajo Generating Station—Salt River Project, Arizona Public Service Co., NV Energy, and Tucson Electric Power—were clear the changing market had everything to do with their decision, writing in their announcement: “The decision by the utility owners of [the Navajo Generating Station] is based on the rapidly changing economics of the energy industry, which has seen natural gas prices sink to record lows and become a viable long-term and economical alternative to coal power.”

And the utility owners have also been clear they want to work with the tribal nations to involve them in future energy projects throughout the state, like expanding the Kayenta Solar Farm, but that’s not enough for many members of the Navajo Nation and Hopi Tribe. They just don’t want to see their livelihood in coal end—and, after all, President Donald Trump promised them (and countless other coal workers) it wouldn’t have to. Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke said in a statement to The Washington Examiner Tuesday the department was committed to keeping the plant open, but presented no formal plan.

Advertisement

More than 200 people were protesting Tuesday, according to The Associated Press. They announced a new coalition: “Yes to NGS.” This coalition aims to advocate for solutions that’d keep these facilities open past 2019. The salary for power plant workers is, on average, $141,500, and that’s seven times more than the median earnings of people on the reservation. That kind of a salary goes a long way, and a job at a nearby facility keeps families close—to each other and their Native culture. Many workers, like Myron Richardson, a 42-year-old Navajo welder at the mine, worry they’ll have to up and move once the mine and power plant close.

“It would be like starting all over again,” Richardson told the AP.

The issue is complicated and divisive among these tribes. Though coal is a source of income, processing it at the plant creates major pollution: 5,000 tons of sulfur dioxide and 20,000 tons of nitrogen oxides (both of which are harmful to the respiratory system and contribute to smog and particulate matter formation) a year, to be exact.

Advertisement
A new coalition rallies outside the Arizona Capitol February 6, 2018, to advocate in support of the Navajo Generating Station. Photo: AP
A new coalition rallies outside the Arizona Capitol February 6, 2018, to advocate in support of the Navajo Generating Station. Photo: AP

At the end of the day, though, the issue comes back to tribal sovereignty and the Navajo and Hopi’s ability to make their own decisions to benefit their families. That’s what many, at least, argue.

Advertisement

“The Navajo Generating Station was developed on tribal lands by tribal workers who mine the coal and create the power that moves water to benefit families and businesses across Arizona,” said United Mine Workers of America President Cecil Roberts, during the rally. “The path forward is for the federal government to maintain its ownership position and continue leading the transition to new owners.”

[h/t The Arizona Republic, The Associated Press]

Advertisement

Yessenia Funes is climate editor at Atmos Magazine. She loves Earther forever.

DISCUSSION

dnapl
Dense non aqueous phase liquid

A really interesting factsheet from NGS and the Navajo Nation Council.

Some of the salient points from the link:

Currently, there are 436 jobs at NGS. The Kayenta Peabody Mine had 519 employees at year end 2014.

Royalties that the Navajo Nation receives from coal would stop in September 2017. SRP has projected 6.7 million tons of coal to be used in 2017. Royalties are projected at $26.8 million per year. Such Royalties fund approximately one-fifth of the general fund. Further, approximately $39M would be lost in 2018 and 2019 combined.

Like any sundowning big polluting industry, there will be lots and lots of work for plant decommissioning and site remediation. The same with the Peabody mine reclamation. The key factor to this creating jobs is surety bonding. Peabody only put aside $235 million for mine reclamation and decommissioning. The others will have to pony up the actual cost.

Put it this way, I know several or more petroleum geologists who after the market crashed for domestic production in the mid 1980s became hydro geologist. Fluid is fluid when it flows through rock and soil. Except fluid physical properties. And then it was oily stuff that was flowing along with groundwater - so there. There will be lots of work for Navajo folks to clean up the mess - and improve water and land use.