Photo: Adam Clark Estes (Gizmodo)

Sony has been trying to crack a tough nut for the past couple of years. The company wants to translate the tremendous success it’s had making over-ear noise-canceling headphones and shrink the technology down to something you can put in your pocket. The new $230 WF-1000XM3 represent its latest attempt at miniaturizing its excellent noise-canceling technology. They also represent some impressive progress, and the result is a terrific set of earbuds unlike anything else on the market.

The first thing I noticed about the 1000XM3 truly wireless earbuds is that they’re not that small. The charging case is almost the size of a pack of cigarettes, and the earbuds look like high-tech mutant hunks of caramel corn. That analogy might only make sense to me, but suffice it say that these things are not as small or as sleek as AirPods. I should also point out that the WF-1000XM3 earbuds are in the same product family as the Sony WH-1000XM3 over-ear headphones, and even borrow some design language from that popular model. However, the earbuds aren’t designed to be a smaller equivalent to the over-ear headphones, which have more microphones and more robust noise-canceling. (To avoid any confusion, I’ll refer to the buds as the 1000XM3 earbuds and the headphones as the 1000XM3 over-ear headphones.)

Advertisement

Part of the 1000XM3's slightly bulky design includes a proximity sensor that, as with the AirPods, turns the earbuds on when you put them in your ears and turns them off when you take them out. In terms of wearing the earbuds, though, size ceases to be a concern.

Advertisement

The earbud itself is about a half an inch long and tucks tightly into your ear canal. The rest of the housing rests outside your ear, though not in a bulky way as with the Bose Soundsport Free. It’s also not an airtight fit, like the Jabra Elite 65t. In my hands-on post for the new Sony earbuds, I pointed out that the slightly loose fit meant that the earbuds struggled to keep out loud noises, like the passing of a subway train. After experimenting with the fit and different sized silicone buds, I managed to get them just right, and now my life is blissfully silent.

The quietude is what makes the Sony 1000XM3 earbuds special. The digital noise canceling in this model is simply the best I’ve encountered in any truly wireless earbuds. I should also say that not many truly wireless earbuds offer noise-canceling features of any kind. Truly wireless earbuds need to be small to fit well, so there’s not a lot of space for batteries and specialized hardware required for noise canceling. While the 1000XM3 aren’t the tiniest earbuds I’ve ever tested, they do offer a dependable six hours of battery life on a single charge. The case buys you another 18 hours of leeway. And that’s with the noise canceling on. Sony says you can get eight hours of battery life on the buds alone without noise canceling, and another 24 hours in the case.

Advertisement

The charging case looks nice, but it sure is big.
Photo: Adam Clark Estes (Gizmodo)

This isn’t Sony’s first attempt at truly wireless noise-canceling buds. The company released the original WF-1000X earbuds back in 2017, and in my opinion, the earbuds fell short in a few different ways. So in updating the model, Sony engineers told me that they included meaningful hardware upgrades that meant the earbuds inner workings started to resemble the lauded WH-1000XM3 noise-canceling headphones. Like those over-ear headphones, each of the 1000XM3 earbuds features a dedicated noise-canceling processor that also works as a digital-to-analog converter (DAC) and an amplifier. This so-called QN1e chip also lets the earbuds communicate with your device independently, so you can just use one and shouldn’t have to worry about the earbuds cutting out. Finally, there are now two microphones on each earbud that improve not only noise-canceling but also voice quality on phone calls.

Advertisement

All of this technical jargon seems excessive, I know. However, performance-wise, the difference between the old 1000X and the new 1000XM3 is dramatic. The noise-canceling is good enough that, when I’m wearing them, people talk to me on the Subway, and I don’t even realize it. (This is often a good thing on the Subway.) My sometimes bustling office also becomes silent when I crank up the noise canceling to max. Tapping the left ear bud lets you switch to Ambient Sound mode, which is convenient if someone’s trying to talk to you while you’re wearing the earbuds. Meanwhile, the Sony Headphones app has a slider that lets you adjust the noise-canceling even more. I’m not sure I would need stronger noise canceling than what the 1000XM3 earbuds offer, except if I were on an airplane. I didn’t get the chance to test the earbuds on a plane, but I know they can’t adjust for atmospheric pressure like Sony’s 1000XM3 over-ear headphones.

I don’t mean to oversell the 1000XM3 earbuds’ noise-canceling capabilities, in general. They’re not as good as a lot of the over-ear noise-canceling headphones I’ve tested. Over-ear headphones have the unique ability to completely isolate your ears while also using more microphones to process the incoming noise. If you’re looking for absolute silence, you should consider spending the extra money and getting the ear muff-style headphones. The sister product to these buds, the Sony 1000XM3 are my favorite such model, although the new Bose Noise Canceling Headphone 700 are also excellent. I will reiterate that I’ve never tested earbuds that cancel noise as well as the Sony WF-1000XM3.

Advertisement

The 1000XM3 earbuds have a proximity sensor on the back, so they turn on when you put them in your ears.
Photo: Adam Clark Estes (Gizmodo)

Where I think the noise-canceling on the new Sony earbuds really shines is in sound quality. When the distracting din of the outside world calmed down, the earbuds do a terrific job with audio fidelity, producing a balanced and detailed experience. The fast-paced percussion and piano on “Bad Man’s Song” by Tears for Fears sounds lively and precise. The glitch-pop classic “Such Great Heights” by Postal Service feels throaty and dreamy at the same time. For a Sony product, the bass response is pleasantly constrained, which I appreciated on “rockstar” by Post Malone. And while the tuning is great out of the box, the equalizer controls in the Sony Headphones app are handy. I should also mention that the 1000XM3 earbuds do not support the apt-X or LDAC codecs, which might annoy some audiophiles out there.

Advertisement

As many nice things as I have to say about the new 1000XM3 earbuds, I’d stop short of making these my daily headphones. For one, Sony makes no claims of waterproofness, so I wouldn’t feel great about wearing these at the gym. (A Sony engineer did say they’d probably fine after exposure to some moisture, but I wouldn’t risk it with the $230 price tag on these things.) I’m also not crazy about the touch controls on the outside of each earbud. One tap should play or pause your music or adjust the noise-canceling—you can program them to do a few different things—but I don’t think the touch surface is responsive enough. It seems like there’s a half-second delay any time I tap them.

Advertisement

There’s also something going on with the connectivity of the earbuds. Like other Sony wireless headphones, they can only connect to one device at a time, which gets irritating if you’re like me and constantly switching from a phone to a laptop. I’ve also noticed that both earbuds don’t seem to connect to a device at the exact same moment. So when I take the earbuds out of the case and put them in my ears, they turn on and connect at slightly different times. I know this because the robotic Sony voice that tells me I’m connected in each ear as soon as the proximity sensor recognizes that I’ve put them in, and I never put them both in simultaneously. Once I’m connected, though, everything seems to work great, and the earbuds seldom cut out. Sony could fix something like this in a software update, but for now, it’s just a little bit annoying.

The earbuds are impressively comfortable and secure-fitting.
Photo: Adam Clark Estes (Gizmodo)

Advertisement

Then again, truly wireless earbuds can be an annoying gadget. The form factor is still incredibly new and even futuristic when you think about it. Sony is moving the ball forward by offering really effective noise-canceling, and that would typically be enough to impress me. The fact that the 1000XM3 earbuds are so slick—they turn on when you put them in your ears and feel comfortable when you’re wearing them—makes me feel like Sony built something special with this model.

That $230 price point is special too. Sure it’s more expensive than $160 AirPods, but the AirPods don’t have noise-canceling. If you’re a true audiophile, you might be willing to spend $300 on the Sennheiser Momentum True Wireless, which have incredible sound quality. But the Sony earbuds also sound great.

Advertisement

The Sony 1000XM3 earbuds (right) are bigger than the Jabra Elite 65t (right).
Photo: Adam Clark Estes (Gizmodo)

As I just said, as impressive as they are, I would stop short of making the Sony 1000XM3 earbuds my daily drivers. I’m just too in love with my $190 Jabra Elite 65t Actives, which are waterproof. Sony says that the 1000XM3 earbuds are made for professionals and travelers. That makes sense. They look smart, and they cram a lot of great features into a small package. I mean, Sony puts noise-canceling in your pocket. That convenience alone is enough for plenty of people.

Advertisement