YouTube's Commenter Controversy Is Putting Creators in a Tricky Position

Illustration for article titled YouTube's Commenter Controversy Is Putting Creators in a Tricky Position
Photo: Chris McGrath (Getty)

As YouTube scrambles to tackle a network of child exploitation in the comments section of its platform, some creators have voiced concern about what will happen if their videos are demonetized amid advertiser pull-outs and crackdowns on content. The Verge reported Friday that a tweet from the Team YouTube account sent creators further spiraling after the company announced a measure it was taking against “inappropriate comments.”


“Over the past few days, we’ve taken a number of actions to better protect the YouTube community from content that endangers minors,” the account tweeted. “With regard to the actions that we’ve taken, even if your video is suitable for advertisers, inappropriate comments could result in your video receiving limited or no ads.”

Advertisers began pulling their ad spending from the site after YouTuber Matt Watson shared a video Sunday that highlighted the methods used by apparent pedophiles in video comments to exploit children, including sharing contact information, captioning videos in an inappropriate manner, and timestamping specific parts of the videos. Faced with losing major ad clients such as Nestlé, Epic Games, and Hasbro, YouTube has taken extreme measures to ensure that ads don’t appear on content that could be a magnet for bad actors.

A spokesperson for YouTube said that it has limited ads on videos that may put young subjects at risk of this kind of predatory activity via comments. YouTube is also shutting the comments off of millions of videos of minors to curb the problem for the time being.

For creators whose videos include their children, for example, limited ads or demonetized videos could be a problem. Some creators tweeted they felt they were being punished for comments beyond their control. Others worry that YouTube’s temporary system could be abused by ill-intentioned commenters looking to screw creators over.

“While the creators of these videos may have done nothing wrong, we’re going above and beyond our existing protections in the near term on content that may include or endanger minors,” Team YouTube wrote in a Friday blog about the changes. “Our goal is to protect creators and the broader ecosystem while we improve our systems.”


In addition to the aforementioned changes, a YouTube spokesperson said earlier this week that the company removed hundreds of accounts linked to individuals leaving what the company perceived to be predatory comments on videos of minors. YouTube is also reporting any illegal comments to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children to work with law enforcement.

“Any content—including comments—that endangers minors is abhorrent and we have clear policies prohibiting this on YouTube,” a YouTube spokesperson said in a statement. “We took immediate action by deleting accounts and channels, reporting illegal activity to authorities and disabling comments on tens of millions of videos that include minors. There’s more to be done, and we continue to work to improve and catch abuse more quickly.”


[The Verge]


Advertisers began pulling their ad spending from the site after YouTuber Matt Watson shared a video

And just for context, that guy seems to have ulterior motives behind all this. His current twitter is brand new, and if you go find his older account..

And over on his old Youtube channel he has videos titled “After watching this you will hate women, reclaim your manhood” and “A camgirl ruined my life”. And even worse. There is a video, this idiot still has it up, where he asks a young girl if she would make an adult video with him.

This guy is not doing this to save children or stop pedophiles. He’s just mad he failed at being internet famous and now wants to ruin YouTube. Advertisers leaving YouTube will not do anything to stop pedophiles. All this does is hurt legitimate content creators.