Why Are New York Bagels the Greatest? It's Not the Water

Image for article titled Why Are New York Bagels the Greatest? It's Not the Water

New York bagels are the best. Deal with it. The legend, according to old city folk, including Larry King, is that there's just something in the water. But Slate's Brian Palmer claims they're wrong.


Water chemistry is only a tiny factor in producing a deliciously crisp and chewy bagel, though the Big Apple's water supply does have lower concentrations of calcium carbonate and magnesium than other metropolitan locales (for the former, it's around 19mg per liter in New York vs. 200mg per liter in parts of LA). The harder the water, the stronger the gluten (and the tougher the bagel).

But the real secrets of the classic NY bagel? First, they ferment their dough, letting it sit overnight in wooden containers, growing yeast and producing flavor compounds. Then most of mom-and-pop shops poach their wares before they bake them, a process that gelatinizes the dough to make it chewy. To cut corners, the less-loving bagel purveyors brush their stuff with water and baking soda, as you might a pretzel, then blast it with steam.

So, sorry Larry and the rest of you Brooklyn bagel water enthusiasts. The proof is in the process. [Slate, Image: Shutterstock]



Saying that New York bagels are the best is like saying the milk from Indiana is the best. Or maybe the more black spots a cow has, the better its milk is.

Taste is an opinion. You cannot prove that something tastes better than something else. Its just impossible. You may come incredibly close, but you cannot prove it. (Pepsi/Coke debate anyone?) In order for it to be a fact, everything must agree. For example, a insect won't care about the difference between a NY bagel and a Californian bagel.