
Private Internet Access and ExpressVPN belong to the same parent company, yet they’re built for different people. PIA puts every setting in front of you and lets you connect as many devices as you own. ExpressVPN keeps most of that behind one button and charges more for the convenience.
So the decision is whether that simplicity, and the higher price, buys something you’ll use every day. I put both through the same speed, streaming, and privacy tests to settle the ExpressVPN vs PIA question one round at a time. Some rounds were close calls, while others had a clear winner.
My recommendation is right below.
Which VPN Should You Choose?
I recommend ExpressVPN. It was faster on distant servers, unblocked far more streaming services, and protects every connection against future quantum attacks without any setup.
- Choose ExpressVPN if you stream catalogs from other countries, want the simplest apps, or travel somewhere that blocks VPNs.
- Choose Private Internet Access if the lowest price decides it, you want every device in a large household covered, or you torrent and want port forwarding.
ExpressVPN vs PIA: Quick Comparison
| Private Internet Access | ExpressVPN | |
| Our Current Ranking | #4 | #3 |
| Price | About $2 a month | About $3 a month |
| Money-Back Guarantee | 30 days | 30 days |
| Free Trial | 7 days on Android and iOS | 3 days on Android |
| Jurisdiction | USA | British Virgin Islands |
| No-Logs Policy | Proven in court, audited | Independently audited, proven by a server seizure |
| Protocols | WireGuard, OpenVPN | Lightway, WireGuard, OpenVPN |
| Post-Quantum Encryption | No | Yes, enabled by default |
| Server Locations | 113 countries, all 50 US states | 113 countries, all 50 US states |
| Netflix Libraries Unblocked | 11 | 25 |
| Ad Blocking | MACE, 96% on our test | Advanced Protection, 71% on our test |
| Smart DNS | Yes | Yes (MediaStreamer) |
| P2P | All servers | All servers |
| Simultaneous Connections | Unlimited | 10 to 14, by plan |
ExpressVPN Is Faster Than PIA: November Speed Test
I tested both from Europe on UK, US, and Japanese servers, with ExpressVPN on Lightway, its own protocol, and PIA on WireGuard, its fastest option.

On nearby servers, the two were close, and you wouldn’t notice the difference while browsing or streaming. Distance changed that. On the Japanese server, PIA lost about a quarter of its download speed, nearly twice ExpressVPN’s loss, so ExpressVPN finished with the lower average.
| UK Download | US Download | Japan Download | Average Download | Average Upload | |
| No VPN (baseline) | 190.36 Mbps | 190.36 Mbps | 190.36 Mbps | 190.36 Mbps | 19.37 Mbps |
| ExpressVPN | 185.74 Mbps (2.4% loss) | 177.03 Mbps (7.0% loss) | 163.94 Mbps (13.9% loss) | 175.57 Mbps (7.8% loss) | 17.64 Mbps (8.9% loss) |
| Private Internet Access | 181.15 Mbps (4.8% loss) | 175.68 Mbps (7.7% loss) | 141.61 Mbps (25.6% loss) | 166.15 Mbps (12.7% loss) | 17.93 Mbps (7.4% loss) |
Uploads went the other way, with PIA losing slightly less. The difference is small enough that sending large files or joining a video call felt the same on both. In practice, either VPN is fast enough at home, and ExpressVPN is the better choice when you regularly connect to a server on another continent.
Winner: ExpressVPN
ExpressVPN Is Better for Streaming
Streaming is where the two VPNs differ most, and Netflix shows it clearly.
| ExpressVPN | Private Internet Access | |
| Netflix libraries | 25 unblocked | 11 unblocked |
| Netflix US, UK, and Canada | Unblocked | Unblocked |
| Netflix Japan | Unblocked | Couldn’t unblock |
| BBC iPlayer | Unblocked | Unblocked |
| Channel 4 | Unblocked | Unblocked |
| ITVX | Unblocked, occasional detection | Unblocked |
| Prime Video | Unblocked, occasional detection | Couldn’t unblock |
| HBO Max | Unblocked | Couldn’t unblock |
| Hulu | Unblocked | Couldn’t unblock |
ExpressVPN’s only Netflix failures were Malaysia and the Philippines, while Hong Kong and Taiwan worked only through its browser extension.

PIA covers the US, UK, and main European catalogs but couldn’t unblock Japan, South Korea, Brazil, or Turkey.

If you choose PIA, start with its streaming-optimized servers, which gave the most consistent results.
Winner: ExpressVPN
Privacy and Security: ExpressVPN Has the Edge
Neither VPN keeps logs of what you do online, and both have had that claim tested outside an audit. ExpressVPN is based in the British Virgin Islands, which has no data retention laws, and it has been independently audited many times, by KPMG among others.
When Turkish investigators seized one of its servers in 2017, they found nothing on it. PIA is based in the US, a Five Eyes member, which sounds worse than PIA’s privacy record shows.
Its no-logs policy has been tested in US court cases, where it had no user data to hand over, and Deloitte has since audited it. PIA also publishes the source code of its apps, so security researchers can inspect what they do.

On security, ExpressVPN is a step ahead. Post-quantum encryption is enabled by default, so traffic captured today should remain unreadable if quantum computers ever break current encryption. PIA doesn’t offer it yet.

Both kill switches, which cut your internet when the VPN drops, passed my tests when I pulled the cable or closed the app. On a PC restart, however, PIA’s default kill switch let my traffic out. I didn’t expect that from a VPN built around privacy.
Enabling the Advanced Kill Switch in its settings fixed it, so do that first if you choose PIA.
Winner: ExpressVPN
PIA Is Cheaper Than ExpressVPN: Pricing Comparison
PIA is one of the cheapest VPNs worth buying. Its two-year plan costs about $2 a month, with a few bonus months added, while the six-month and monthly plans cost more. ExpressVPN sells three plans: Basic, Advanced, and Express Pro.
The Basic plan costs about $3 a month on its two-year term, and the higher plans add devices, a password manager, and, in the US, identity protection.
| Two-Year Plan | Monthly Plan | Devices | |
| PIA | About $2 a month | About $12 | Unlimited |
| ExpressVPN Basic plan | About $3 a month | About $15 | 10 |
Renewal is where the two differ most. PIA’s two-year plan renews every year at the same total you paid for the first term. By contrast, ExpressVPN’s Basic plan renews at nearly twice PIA’s yearly price.
Winner: Private Internet Access
PIA Has More Features, Especially for Torrenting
PIA has more tools for experienced users. MACE, its ad and tracker blocker, stopped 96% of the ads and trackers on our blocking test.

ExpressVPN’s Advanced Protection stopped 71%.

Split tunneling, which lets chosen apps bypass the VPN, also goes further on PIA, since it works with IP addresses and domains as well as apps.

On top of that, Multi-Hop sends your connection through a proxy before the VPN server, so your ISP sees the proxy’s country and websites see the VPN server’s. As for extras you pay for, PIA’s dedicated IP, an IP address only you use, costs about $2.50 a month in 26 locations.
ExpressVPN sells one as an add-on on the Basic and Advanced plans and includes it with Express Pro. PIA also offers an antivirus add-on for Windows. For torrenting, both VPNs allow P2P on every server, and neither leaked in my tests.

Even so, PIA has the stronger setup. Port forwarding, which opens a port so more peers can connect to you, can speed up torrent downloads. It isn’t available on US servers, so connect to a Canadian or European one.

ExpressVPN doesn’t offer port forwarding in its apps.
Winner: Private Internet Access
ExpressVPN Is Easier to Use
Both VPNs have apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, iPhone, Android, Apple TV, and routers, and either one installs on a Firestick from the Amazon app store.
For smart TVs and consoles without app support, both offer Smart DNS, a setting that changes the device’s DNS so streaming services see another country. ExpressVPN calls its version MediaStreamer. ExpressVPN’s apps are the easier of the two for a first-time user.

You connect with one tap, a search bar finds any location, and the apps look much the same on every device. PIA’s mobile apps are simple too. Its desktop app, however, looks dated and crowded with settings, which experienced users will appreciate more than beginners.

Device limits favor PIA. It lets you connect as many devices as you like, while ExpressVPN allows 10 on the Basic plan and up to 14 on Express Pro.
Winner: ExpressVPN
ExpressVPN Works Better Where VPNs Are Blocked
ExpressVPN disguises every connection automatically, on every server, so it looks like ordinary web traffic to a network that filters VPNs. That process, called obfuscation, requires no settings to find. As a result, ExpressVPN is a strong option for VPN use in China and other countries where networks detect and block standard VPN connections.
PIA’s obfuscation is a Shadowsocks proxy in its Multi-Hop settings. It works only with OpenVPN, so you have to switch protocols first, and it covers a short list of locations. That’s enough for a school or office network that blocks VPNs. In a country that blocks them nationwide, though, it means more setup and fewer options.
Winner: ExpressVPN
Server Network: A Draw
ExpressVPN and PIA have servers in 113 countries and in all 50 US states, so you can get a local IP address in almost any state you’re after. ExpressVPN divides its network into 214 locations you can choose in the app.
PIA, for its part, adds streaming-optimized servers in several countries, which unblocked Netflix more often than its standard ones. Neither VPN publishes a total server count. Finally, both use RAM-only servers, which wipe stored data every time a server restarts.
Verdict
ExpressVPN wins five rounds to two, with one draw, and its wins are in the areas you notice daily. Distant servers were faster, far more Netflix libraries worked, and the apps required no setup beyond signing in. Post-quantum encryption is a technical lead PIA hasn’t answered yet. Still, PIA’s two wins are significant.
It’s much cheaper to keep after the first term, and its torrenting tools go further than anything ExpressVPN offers. So the decision depends on how you use a VPN. If streaming and travel are why you’re buying one, ExpressVPN is worth the extra money. If you mostly browse and torrent at home, PIA does that for less.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is PIA better than ExpressVPN?
No, not for most people. ExpressVPN is faster on distant servers, unblocks more streaming services, and has simpler apps. PIA is cheaper, allows unlimited devices, and offers port forwarding for torrenting.
Are PIA and ExpressVPN owned by the same company?
Yes. Kape Technologies owns both, along with CyberGhost. The two VPNs still have separate apps, server networks, and privacy policies, and each commissions its own independent audits.
Is PIA safe even though it's based in the US?
Yes. PIA's no-logs policy has held up in US court cases, where it had no user data to share, and an independent audit has verified it. Its apps are also open source.
Which is cheaper, PIA or ExpressVPN?
PIA is cheaper. It costs less than ExpressVPN on every plan length and renews at a lower price, while ExpressVPN's higher plans add more devices and identity protection.
Does ExpressVPN allow unlimited devices?
No. ExpressVPN limits simultaneous connections, and the limit increases on its higher plans. PIA has no device limit, so one subscription covers every phone, computer, and TV in a household.